Why Aren’t All Butches Trans?
From Butch Wonders:
As a butch who has great respect for trans men but no desire to be one, I have a few answers to the “why aren’t all butches trans” question.
- First, gender is culturally imposed. The idea that men should wear ties and women should wear dresses is not biologically embedded in our brains. If a woman wants to sample/use/enjoy “male” culture, why would this necessarily indicate that she would also want facial hair and a penis? To me, the two feel totally separate.
- “Genderqueer” means different things to different people. But I most often hear it defined as existing outside the gender binary—someone who sees themselves as neither male, nor female.
- “Genderqueer” is a fashionable thing to be right now. But you need not identify as genderqueer just because you are a butchy dyke, or a cross-dressing man, or a transwoman, or anything else. You can be a man in a dress who completely identifies as a man, or a woman in a tie who completely identifies as a woman. Personally, I am not genderqueer. I look rather butch/androgynous, but I completely identify as female. Just because a woman has short hair, or binds her breasts, or wears a tie, does not mean she is automatically “genderqueer.”
(more at the link)